If you’re planning on taking the Security+ exam, you should have a basic understanding of implementing environmental controls that directly contribute to the availability of systems and understand when to consider value of personal safety.
For example, can you answer this question?
Q. An attacker was able to sneak into your building but was unable to open the server room door. He bashed the proximity badge reader with a portable fire extinguisher and the door opened. What is the MOST likely reason that the door opened?
A. The access system was designed to fail-open.
B. The access system was designed to fail-close.
C. The access system was improperly installed.
D. The portable fire extinguisher included a proximity badge.
More, do you know why the correct answer is correct and the incorrect answers are incorrect? The answer and explanation is available at the end of this post.
Fail-Safe Versus Fail-Open
Many times, it’s important to consider the state of a system if it fails. You can often force a system to fail in an open state, or to fail in a safe or secure state. The terms fail-safe, fail-secure, and fail-close all mean the same thing. The state you choose is often dependent on the needs of the organization.
For example, you may have a system that requires high availability, but security isn’t as important. If it fails, you would want it to fail in an open state so that it remains available.
Consider an exit door secured with a proximity card. Normally, employees open the door with the proximity card and the system records their exit. The proximity card provides security, but you need the exit to remain highly available.
What happens if a fire starts and power to the building is lost? The proximity card reader won’t work, and if the door can’t open, employees will be trapped. In this case, you would want the proximity card reader to fail in the fail-open state so that personnel can get out. The value of personnel safety is always paramount. Of course, this does introduce a vulnerability. An attacker might be able to access a secure data center by destroying a proximity card reader.
On the other hand, consider a firewall used to provide security for a network. In this case, security is more important than availability. For example, if a firewall access control list (ACL) became corrupt, you would want it to fail in a fail-safe or secure mode. Essentially, it would block all traffic and continue to provide security for the network.
Fire Suppression
You can fight fires with individual fire extinguishers, with fixed systems, or both. Most organizations included fixed systems to control fires and place portable fire extinguishers in different areas around the organization. A fixed system can detect a fire and automatically activate to extinguish the fire. Individuals use portable fire extinguishers to suppress small fires.
The different components of a fire are heat, oxygen, fuel, and a chain reaction creating the fire. Fire suppression methods attempt to remove or disrupt one of these elements to extinguish a fire. You can extinguish a fire using one of these methods:
- Remove the heat. Fire extinguishers commonly use chemical agents or water to remove the heat. However, water should never be used on an electrical fire.
- Remove the oxygen. Many methods use a gas, such as carbon dioxide (CO2) to displace the oxygen. This is a common method of fighting electrical fires because CO2 and similar gasses are harmless to electrical equipment.
- Remove the fuel. Fire-suppression methods don’t typically fight a fire this way, but of course, the fire will go out once all the material is burned.
- Disrupt the chain reaction. Some chemicals can disrupt the chain reaction of fires to stop them.
The class of fire often determines what element of the fire you will try to remove or disrupt. Within the United States, fires are categorized in one of the following fire classes:
- Class A—Ordinary combustibles. These include wood, paper, cloth, rubber, trash, and plastics.
- Class B—Flammable liquids. These include gasoline, propane, solvents, oil, paint, lacquers, and other synthetics or oil-based products.
- Class C—Electrical equipment. This includes computers, wiring, controls, motors, and appliances. The CompTIA Security+ exam is computer-centric, so you should especially understand that a Class C fire is from electrical equipment. You should not fight Class C fires with water or water-based materials, such as foam, because the water is conductive and can pose significant risks to personnel.
- Class D—Combustible metals. This includes metals such as magnesium, lithium, titanium, and sodium. Once they start to burn, they are much more difficult to extinguish than other materials.
You can extinguish a Class A fire with water to remove the heat. However, water makes things much worse if you use it on any of the other classes. For example, using water on live equipment actually poses a risk because electricity can travel up the water stream and shock you. Additionally, water damages electrical equipment.
Q. An attacker was able to sneak into your building but was unable to open the server room door. He bashed the proximity badge reader with a portable fire extinguisher and the door opened. What is the MOST likely reason that the door opened?
A. The access system was designed to fail-open.
B. The access system was designed to fail-close.
C. The access system was improperly installed.
D. The portable fire extinguisher included a proximity badge.
Answer is A. In this scenario, the most likely reason that the door opened was because the access system was designed to fail-open for personnel safety.
If the system was designed to fail-close, then employees would be trapped inside during a fire or other disaster.
Nothing in the scenario indicates the system was improperly installed.
A fire extinguisher would not include a proximity badge, and it wouldn’t work if the proximity reader was destroyed.