If you’re planning to take the SY0-501 version of the Security+ exam, you should understand the importance of physical security controls. Physical security access controls attempt to control entry and exit.
For example, can you answer this question?
Q. A security professional has reported an increase in the number of tailgating violations into a secure data center. Which of the following can prevent this?
A. CCTV
B. Mantrap
C. Proximity card
D. Cipher lock
More, do you know why the correct answer is correct and the incorrect answers are incorrect? The answer and explanation are available at the end of this post.
Door Lock
It’s common to secure access to controlled areas of a building with door locks, and there are many different lock types. A door access system is one that only opens after some access control mechanism is used. Some common door access systems are cipher locks, proximity cards, and biometrics.
When implementing door access systems, it’s important to limit the number of entry and exit points. As an example, if a data center has only one entrance and exit, it is much easier to monitor this single access point. You can control it with door locks, video surveillance, and guards. On the other hand, if the data center has two entry/exit points, you need another set of controls to control access in both places.
Another important consideration with door access systems is related to personnel safety and fire. In the event of a fire, door access systems should allow personnel to exit the building without any form of authentication.
Tailgating
Tailgating (also called piggybacking) occurs when one user follows closely behind another user without using credentials. For example, if Lisa opens a door with her proximity card and Bart follows closely behind her without using a proximity card, Bart is tailgating. If authorized users routinely do this, it indicates the environment is susceptible to a social engineering attack where an unauthorized user follows closely behind an authorized user.
Most of us learn to be polite and courteous and social engineers take advantage of this. It’s polite to hold a door open for people who have their hands full. In contrast, it’s rude to slam the door in the face of someone following behind us. However, most users don’t want to help criminals. Security awareness programs and training help users understand how criminals use tactics such as tailgating. Educated users are less likely to be tricked, even by a friendly smile from an attractive woman.
High-traffic areas are most susceptible to tailgating attacks. Security guards can be an effective preventive measure at access points, but they need to be vigilant to ensure that tailgating does not occur. The best solution is a mantrap.
Preventing Tailgating with Mantraps
A mantrap is a physical security mechanism designed to control access to a secure area through a buffer zone. Personnel use something like a proximity card to gain access, and the mantrap allows one person, and only one person, to pass through. Because they only allow one person through at a time, mantraps prevent tailgating. Mantraps get their name due to their ability to lock a person between two areas, such as an open access area and a secure access area, but not all of them are that sophisticated.
An example of a simple mantrap is a turnstile similar to what you see in many public transport systems. Even if you’ve never ridden the subway in one of many U.S. cities or the Tube in London, you’ve probably seen turnstiles in movies such as While You Were Sleeping. When customers present a token, the turnstile unlocks and allows a single person through at a time. Similarly, users unlock the turnstile mantrap with something like a proximity card.
A sophisticated mantrap is a room, or even a building, that creates a large buffer area between the secure area and the unsecured area. Access through the entry door and the exit door is tightly controlled, either with guards or with an access card such as a proximity card.
It’s also possible to require identification and authentication before allowing passage through a mantrap. For example, a retina scanner can identify individuals and restrict access to only authorized individuals. Similarly, some card reader systems support the use of unique PINs assigned to the user. Users present their card and enter their PIN to gain access before the mantrap opens.
Increasing Physical Security with Guards
Many organizations use security guards to control access to buildings and secure spaces. If employees have ID badges, guards can check these badges prior to granting the employees access. Even if ID badges aren’t used, guards can still verify people’s identity using other identification. Similarly, the security guards can restrict access by checking people’s identity against a preapproved access control list. In some cases, guards record all access in an access log. Security guards can also take a less-active role to deter security incidents. For example, a security guard can deter tailgating incidents by observing personnel when they use their proximity card to gain access to a secure area.
Q. A security professional has reported an increase in the number of tailgating violations into a secure data center. Which of the following can prevent this?
A. CCTV
B. Mantrap
C. Proximity card
D. Cipher lock
Answer is B. A mantrap is highly effective at preventing unauthorized entry and can also be used to prevent tailgating.
CCTV uses cameras for video surveillance and it can record unauthorized entry, but it can’t prevent
A proximity card is useful as an access control mechanism, but it won’t prevent tailgating, so it isn’t as useful as a mantrap.
A cipher lock is a door access control, but it can’t prevent tailgating.
See Chapter 9 of the CompTIA Security+: Get Certified Get Ahead: SY0-501 Study Guide for more information on physical security controls.